Wirth Consulting

For in-depth print and business-process workflow research and insight

Our Testing Reveals that HP Printer Inks Do Not ‘Dry Out’

by · Published · Updated

Disclosure: Wirth Consulting was commissioned by Hewlett-Packard to perform the following test as part of an internal study intended to determine the effects of extended periods of non-use of HP OEM inks that are currently in use worldwide, and applicable host printers, under controlled conditions. Wirth Consulting was granted permission to publish the test results, as well as the distribution of the final test report.

HP commissioned Wirth Consulting to perform this testing specifically because we are a non-biased, third-party, independent testing company that employs good lab practices. Read on and you will realize that although the results of the test were not ultimately perfect, the tested HP ink and printer products produced solid results in which none of the tested inks “dried out.”

SIGNIFICANCE AND USE

Some technology takes longer than others to mature. For example, consider inkjet-imaging technology. Decades ago, some very early inkjet printers were finicky and did not deliver consistent print quality. The same however was true of early copier technology as well. Unfortunately, only with inkjet technology are there lingering doubts about its integrity – a common misconception being that inkjet printers “dry out” when they are left unused – that is, the print quality becomes “unacceptable” at some point in time. HP is well aware of this misconception and its internal research indicates that the ink formulas used with the latest HP printers can perform to “specification” after considerable periods of printer inactivity. However, what methodology was used to support such claims? What was the “inactivity” time-frame? How was “unacceptable” print quality determined? Needless to say, verification and replication of these claims by a third-party source that utilizes good lab practices would add considerable value to HP’s research.

Recognizing this, Wirth Consulting developed and employed the following test program to verify that OEM HP ink supplies will perform after 90 and 180 days of inactivity.

In order to perform this test, we purchased, unboxed, and installed twenty-four (24) HP inkjet printer models sourced from around the world.

 

SCOPE

Determine the OEM ink types currently used in HP printers worldwide. For each type of ink, obtain two HP test units on the open market. Set-up the printers and divide them into two groups, with 1) one group undergoing a 90-day inactivity test, and 2) another group undergoing a 180-day inactivity test.

Perform testing under controlled conditions. Determine if selected HP printers equipped with OEM ink can remain idle and powered off, and then print to specification when powered back on after 90 and 180 days of inactivity.

Note: For full details you can view and download the full Hands-On Test Report here.