Jury Awards Canon Nearly $4.5 Million for Toner-Bottle Patent Infringement
World Intellectual Property Review reports that a federal jury has awarded Canon Inc. a $4.5 million award after finding that a plastic manufacturer and a toner company “wilfully infringed” upon a Canon patent involving Canon toner bottles.
The jury handed won the verdict on Monday, June 19th, at the US District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, Atlanta Division. The jury found that two companies infringed on the Canon patent: General Plastic, which it order to pay Canon $3.7 million, and Color Imaging, which it ordered to pay Canon $730,000.
In 2011, Canon sued both companies for infringing upon its patent, number 7,647,012, that related to toner bottles used for supplying product Canon imageRUNNER copier/MFPs with toner..
Canon said in its complaint: “Defendants market their toner bottle products as purported alternatives to genuine toner bottle products manufactured by Canon and sold under the Canon brand name…. Defendants’ acts complained of herein are damaging and will continue to cause irreparable injury and damage to Canon for which there is no adequate remedy at law.”
The jury unanimously found that Canon had successfully proven that the parties infringed upon the ‘012 Canon patent.
- June 2017: German Court Grants Canon Injunction in Printer-Supplies Patent-Infringement Dispute
- June 2017: Canon Resolves Patent-Infringement Litigation with J&H Greentech and Trading
- April 2015: Printronic Agrees to Not Sell Alleged Canon Patent-Infringing Toner Cartridges, Drums, in U.S.
- February 2015: X Com Shop Agrees to Stop Selling Toner Cartridges that Allegedly Infringe Upon Canon Patents